工频输电与低频输电载流能力对比及经济性分析
Comparison and Economic Analysis of Current Carrying Capacity between Power Frequency Transmission and Low-Frequency Transmission
-
摘要: 为对比分析工频输电与低频输电系统在载流能力和经济性方面的差异,文中利用COMSOL软件建立了电磁-热-流耦合仿真模型,对工频和低频海上风电传输系统进行了载流量分析,并计算了系统中的设备成本和损耗成本,以对比工频输电和低频输电的经济性。研究结果表明,当电压等级、电缆截面和电缆敷设参数保持不变时,降低负载频率,海底电缆导体损耗、护套损耗和铠装损耗均会出现不同程度的减少,且随着负载电流的增加,降低趋势更为明显;与工频输电相比,低频输电在不同输电情况下,海底电缆的导体截面可以降低1~3个等级;当采用低频输电时,电缆截面较小容易导致海缆内部导体损耗增加,但由于护套损耗和铠装损耗的降低,总损耗在同等容量下相较于工频输电呈下降趋势;在海上风电场容量为600 MW、输电线路采用220 kV海底电缆的条件下,传输距离增至32 km时,柔性低频交流输电技术的经济性优势开始显现。结果分析可为新型电力传输系统的发展提供数据支撑。Abstract: In order to compare and analyze transmission capability and economy of low-frequency transmission system and power frequency transmission system,electromagnetic,thermal and current coupling simulation model was established by COMSOL,current carrying capacity of power frequency and low frequency offshore wind power transmission system was analyzed,and equipment cost and loss cost in system were calculated,so as to make economic comparison between power frequency and low-frequency transmission.Results showed that when voltage level,cable section and cable laying parameters remained unchanged,submarine cable phase loss,sheath loss and armor loss all decreased to varying degrees with decrease of load frequency,and the decreasing trend was more obvious with gradual increase of load current.Compared with power frequency transmission,the cross section of submarine cable conductor could be reduced by 1-3 grades according to different transmission conditions.When low-frequency transmission was used,the smaller cross section led to increase of internal phase loss of submarine cable,but sheath loss and armor loss were reduced,and total loss was lower than that of power frequency transmission with the same capacity.When capacity of offshore wind farm was 600 MW,transmission line adopted 220 kV submarine cable,and when transmission distance increased to 32 km,the economic advantages of flexible low-frequency transmission technology began to appear.Results could provide data support for future new power transmission system.